I made these Over the Garden Wall cookies for my daughter’s husband’s birthday. They are both big fans of the show. These cookies feature Wirt, Greg, the Highwayman, and a pumpkin person carving a pumpkin.
The Greg cookie has him wearing the teapot and carrying the frog. He is surrounded by fall colors or orange, yellow, and brown. His pose and Wirt’s pose in the following cookie are both from the a picture in the Wikipedia article about the television show.
The Wirt cookie has him and the bird Beatrice. He is surrounded by fall colors or orange, yellow, and brown.
The Highwayman cookie has the sailing ship and a whale in the background.
This Pumpkin man cookies features the pumpkin man carving a pumpkin. This cookie was inspired by this Over the Garden Wall poster by Mark Hardin. All of these cookies are based on scenes in the Over the Garden Wall television series.
